Supreme Court Finds Disciplinary Punishment Against Doctor Vengeful

Supreme Court Finds Disciplinary Punishment Against Doctor Vengeful

  • Case Name: Bhupinderpal Singh Gill vs. State of Punjab & Ors.
  • Judge(s): Justices Dipankar Datta and Justice Manmohan

The Supreme Court set aside a disciplinary penalty imposed on a retired Punjab Senior Medical Officer, citing procedural unfairness and vengeful intent. 

The penalty, stemming from alleged leave violations and non-participation in a polio program, was deemed a ploy to punish the doctor for suing state officials to recover legitimate dues. 

The Court highlighted procedural lapses, lack of evidence, and non-adherence to Election Commission directives exempting retirees from election duty. 

Terming the proceedings arbitrary and punitive, the Court awarded ₹50,000 compensation, allowing Punjab to recover the amount from errant officials.

The judgment reinforces safeguards for public servants under Article 311.

Verdictum / 9 months ago

 AnviBookmark